Piano tuning tools


A Look At Piano Styles


Vertical and grand pianos


Pondering ponderous pontificationsBack to FAQ

Sticking keys

Fix pedals

Get stuff
out of grand actions


Get stuff
from vertical pianos


Replace
old keytops


Fix Wobbly
benches


Moving
your piano



Buying A Piano?
Buy smart.

(Opens new window)


There are two types of modern acoustic pianos, VERTICALS and GRANDS. Of the vertical pianos, there are four basic styles; the Upright, Console, Studio and Spinet. Since piano makers frequently vary the size of their cabinet work in different vertical models it's often difficult to distinguish between a console and a spinet, or a studio and an upright, simply by looking at the case. Technically, the classification of these styles is determined by the placement of the action (i.e., the collection of parts that strike the strings) in relation to the keyboard, as shown in the following drawing:

vertical piano styles On full Uprights the action is ABOVE the keys and connected to them by a wooden rod called a sticker. The Console action is compressed to save room and rides directly ON the keys (or a small brass capstan screw on the key end) and is called a direct blow action. Spinets actions are called drop actions and are placed BELOW the keyboard, connected to the keys by a wire or wood rod called a lifter. Studio pianos use a direct blow action, like a console, but the case is taller and the action full sized like the upright. The extra height of the studio gives it longer strings and a bigger soundboard than the spinet, though less than a full upright.

In theory, the console action would seem to be superior to the other two due to its simpler construction. In fact, however, there is little difference between the upright and console in terms of keyboard response -- and certainly not enough to make up for the upright's superior tonal qualities, which can be attributed to its longer strings and larger soundboard.

The spinet drop action, on the other hand, is just a bad idea all the way around. It adds a troublesome and noisy "lifter," which makes it difficult to remove the action (and hence makes servicing more expensive). Also, to place the action below the keyboard, the keys have been shortened, seriously compromising key balance and making the spinet action loose and sloppy. In addition, the spinet's shorter, heavier wound bass strings and small soundboard make for a less resonant bass tone.

The irony of the spinet design is that it was intended to save weight and space, yet in fact, is the same width and depth (and nearly the same weight) as the console and uses just as much floor space. The only space saved is between the top of the piano and the ceiling. Hmmmm! Nonetheless, spinets remain popular and their resale value is high, though at the moment they are no longer being built. Most are perfectly adequate for amateur players, despite their shortcomings. Perhaps the best spinet was the Acrosonic, produced by the Baldwin Piano Company.

Grand Pianos

grand pianos are always horizontal in constructionGrand pianos are wing shaped and are ALWAYS horizontal in construction, as in this picture, hence there is no such thing as an "Upright Grand," though many Victorian piano makers labeled their instruments with that misnomer as a sales gimmick to cash in on the grand piano's prestige. Grands come in several sizes including the baby grand, which is usually around 5'6" from the keyboard to the back of the case. Parlor grand was a name given to instruments 6 or 7 feet in length, and of course a concert grand, the top of the line, is 9 feet in length. The extra string length and soundboard size of these big grands, along with their handmade construction, gives them a tonal quality and volume unmatched by any of the smaller models (it also gives them an unmatched price tag -- some, such as Bosendorfer, sell for over $150,000 -- your little spinet is looking a bit better, huh?). As a matter of fact, grand pianos are always superior to all verticals, due to a better action design and a quicker key response, and are the choice of most serious performers who can afford them.

Oddities

The antique Square GrandAn old style of piano once very popular is the square grand. These things look like a large coffin with legs, and you will often see them in old movies and some museums, but only rarely in the real world. They were last produced by Steinway in 1896, though they were obsolete 40 years earlier. The construction of these old pianos was eccentric, to say the least, with a keyboard that had very long bass keys and very short treble keys (or maybe it was the other way around, I forget), making playing them an adventure. Tuning them was more like a nightmare.

If you happen to stumble onto one of these beasts in your local antique store, I suggest you resist the urge to buy it unless you're needing something to bury your uncle in (in which case be sure to hire plenty of pallbearers as these old monsters weight a ton). They were a mess even when new, due to the design, and are all virtually unplayable nowadays. As parts are no longer made, they are also not re-buildable (except by antique instrument restorers. If you happen to own one of these beasts, visit the Antique Piano Shop for a fine history of square grands and how to get them restored to playable condition. Link leaves this site)

Another odd-ball piano style that can sometimes be found in antique stores is the old European cottage piano. These pianos were small uprights, usually with fancy carvings on the case and often with elaborate candle holders on the front. They can be easily recognized if you remove the front of the case and view the action. Due to an obsolete arrangement of the dampers above the hammers rather than behind them (called "Overdamper"), the mass of damper connecting wires gives the action the appearance of a birdcage, hence they were known to technicians by that nickname. If you think you have this type of piano, you'll know as soon as you remove the front piece (see a detailed description with photos of Overdamper pianos at David Boyce's website -- link leaves this site).

Despite their obsolete design these pianos were still manufactured into the 20th century and sometimes imported to America by British and German makers with a sense of humor. As with the square grand you should resist the urge to buy one unless you simply want it as furniture. They are difficult if not impossible to tune and nearly always impossible to repair as parts are no longer manufactured.

Another oddity of some European pianos, incidentally, is a shortened keyboard; i.e., 85 keys rather than the usual 88. This key arrangement does not necessarily date the piano as some makers have continued to produce them. Frankly, the last three treble keys were only added to piano keyboards in the late 19th century at the request of some flashy concert pianists. Most players can get by perfectly well without them, except in some very advanced 20th century concert compositions. Beethoven, Mozart and most other "classical" composers got along with keyboards that were an octave or more shorter than the modern 88 standard. In fact, the strings on these last three notes notes are so short, and the hammer striking point so precise, that they often sound more like a metallic thud than a musical tone, except on the very best of the big grands.

For more information on antique pianos and their history, vist Antique Piano Emporium.